Becoming a member of the LoveReading community is free.

No catches, no fine print just unadulterated book loving, with your favourite books saved to your own digital bookshelf.

New members get entered into our monthly draw to win £100 to spend in your local bookshop Plus lots lots more…

Find out more

A More Perfect Union

by Tammye Huf

Relationship Stories Literary Fiction Debut Books of the Month Debuts Historical fiction Sharing Diverse Voices Star Books

LoveReading Expert Review of A More Perfect Union

Rich with romance and rawly affecting slave history, this exceptional debut tells an unforgettable tale of love between a black slave and an Irish immigrant in pre-Civil War Virginia.

Based on her great-great grandparents’ experiences, Tammye Huf’s A More Perfect Union is a heart-rending, soul-stirring story of the love between a black slave and an Irish immigrant. A lucid, bold tale of the despicable brutality of slavery, personal conflicts, and a bond that will not be broken.

Henry O’Toole fled Ireland in 1848 to escape the famine. On arriving in New York, “America stabs me with homesickness” and he can’t find a job - “Every day it’s the same. No Irish”. Compelled to flee the city, he changes his surname to the English-sounding ‘Taylor’ and heads to Virginia.

House slave Sarah is separated from her Momma and brother when she’s sold as a “quick-cleaning-slave-who-don’t-get-sick”. She and Henry meet when he comes seeking work as a blacksmith at the plantation she’s been sold to. Here Henry is moved by the sound of slaves singing at night, while Sarah paces her hoe in the kitchen garden to “the rhythmic strike of the blacksmith’s hammer”. The stirring attraction between them is palpable, but theirs is a forbidden relationship - inter-racial marriage is illegal, and viewed as an abomination. What’s more, she’s owned by another man.

The couple are in an excruciating situation, their complex personal conflicts evoked with shattering clarity. Sarah has to reconcile loving a man whose white skin represents her oppression, and she’s also ostracised by fellow slaves. Then there’s the searing exchange when Sarah sees Henry making neck rings and shackles. When he protests that he has no choice, that he needs to earn money, that he knows what it is to be shackled by poverty, Sarah’s response captures the despicable inhumanity of enslavement: “’I know you been through a hard, hungry life,’ she says. ‘I want you to understand that slave suffering is a different thing. When somebody owns you, there ain’t nothing they can’t do to you.’” 

Both their voices are conjured with brilliant authenticity, and their story builds to an agonisingly edgy crescendo as the risks they take are as immense as their love. I cannot recommend this enough.

Head to our 'Black Lit Matters' list to find more must-read novels by black writers.

Joanne Owen

A More Perfect Union Synopsis

Henry O'Toole sails to America in 1848 to escape poverty and famine in Ireland, only to find anti-Irish prejudice awaiting him. Determined never to starve again, he changes his surname to Taylor and heads south to the state of Virginia, seeking work as a travelling blacksmith on the prosperous plantations. Sarah is a slave. Torn from her family and sold to Jubilee Plantation, she must navigate the hierarchy of her fellow slaves, the whims of her white masters, and now the attentions of the mysterious blacksmith. Fellow slave Maple oversees the big house with bitterness and bile, and knows that a white man's attention spells trouble. Given to her half-sister as a wedding present by their white father, she is set on being reunited with her husband and daughter, at any cost. Research included contemporary slave narratives (printed to further the abolitionist cause), digitally remastered audio recordings of former slaves, legislation on the question of slavery in the mid-19th century, historical texts on the Irish famine and first-hand accounts of English visitors to Ireland at the time, the writings of Charles Trevelyan (responsible for famine relief under Peel and Russell), historical texts on the antebellum South, and visits to the historically preserved Jubilee Plantation in Virginia on which the novel's plantation is based.

Win the 2021 Women's Prize for Fiction Shortlist!

Win the 2021 Women's Prize for Fiction Shortlist!

Closing date: 30/05/2021

The Women's Prize for Fiction is one of the most prestigious literary awards in the world. To celebrate their announcement of the 2021 Shortlist, we are offering one lucky person the opportunity to win the entire shortlist! You can find out everything you need to know about the prize here: You can also be among the first to hear the latest Women’s Prize news by subscribing to their newsletter. You can sign up by clicking the link here: The LoveReading team have read and love a number of the books on this year's shortlist. Our Reviews Editor, Liz Robinson thinks Unsettled Ground by Claire Fuller is an "emotionally intelligent and beautiful novel". Expert Reviewer Joanne Owen feels that Yaa Gyasi's Transcendent Kingdom is an "eloquent, incisive novel seeps into the soul", that The Vanishing Half by Brit Bennet is "a compelling, compassionate, consummately outstanding novel" and Cherie Jones is "a writer to watch" after reading How The One-Armed Sister Sweeps Her House. We’re thrilled to be a part of the announcement of the 2021 Women’s Prize for Fiction Shortlist. Join the conversation with the #WomensPrize on social media and let us know which books you’re looking forward to reading. This draw is open only for UK residents currently in the UK and is free to enter, multiple entries from the same email address will only be counted once. The draw closes on 30th May 2021. Please ensure that the details you use to enter the competition will be correct at the time the competition ends. The winners will be notified as soon as possible.

Enter Now

Like For Like Featured Books

How the One-Armed Sister Sweeps Her House
Mrs Death Misses Death
Shuggie Bain

Other editions of this book

ISBN: 9781912408979
Publication date: 03/06/2021
Format: Paperback

ISBN: 9781912408894
Publication date: 15/10/2020
Format: Hardback

View All Editions

More Books By Tammye Huf

A More Perfect Union
View All Books By Tammye Huf

Share this book