Win a Family Weekend Break with Lovereading and VisitWiltshire - click here for details...

debuts of the month join us on facebook
Search our site
Are You Sleeping by Kathleen Barber Read the opening extract of the brand new Kathleen Barber book before its publication on 27/12/2017

Bush v. Gore The Court Cases and the Commentary by E. J., Jr. Dionne

Bush v. Gore The Court Cases and the Commentary



Bush v. Gore The Court Cases and the Commentary by E. J., Jr. Dionne

On December 12, 2000, a controversial decision by the Supreme Court of the United States effectively ended the disputed presidential contest between George W. Bush and Albert Gore Jr. with a 5-4 ruling that revealed the court to be as bitterly divided as the electorate. Four days earlier, the Florida Supreme Court had abruptly changed the dynamics of the election by reversing a lower court and ordering hand recounts of undervotes statewide. The U.S. Supreme Court quickly stepped in to halt the recounts and agreed to hear Bush v. Gore. After brief oral arguments and a short period of deliberation, the high court reversed the state court decision. The justices in both cases were bitterly divided, and passionate language emerged in both the majority rulings and the dissents. The drama and divisiveness of this extraordinary saga come to life in the rulings, opinions, and dissents from these two cases: U.S. Supreme Court case 00-949 (Bush v. Gore) and Florida Supreme Court case 00-2431 (Gore v. Harris). The first section of this volume gathers the complete text of both rulings, along with selections from oral arguments in the U.S. Supreme Court case. The second section of the book gathers the most significant opinion pieces from journalists and scholars on both sides of the political fence. Selected and organized by political analysts E.J. Dionne and William Kristol, these articles illuminate the perspectives of both sides about the various twists and turns in the post-election campaign, and the landmark judicial intervention. A companion website will provide links to documents from additional legal proceedings and other related documents and writings. The legal and historical significance of the 2000 election will be studied and debated for years to come. This volume combines the most important source documents with the most intelligent opinion and analysis about the conflict and its controversial resolution.


A 'must
for students of political science and American electorial history.

-- Midwest Book Review, 4/18/2001 Kristol and Dionne's collection stand[s] up well as an account of the 'outside story
in Florida.

--Richard Lowry, National Review, 4/19/2001 'Bush v. Gore
is essential reading

... It features a wide range of intelligent commentary, from hard-hitting leftist critiques in The Nation, to confused centrist plaints in The New Republic, to jarring conservative responses in The Weekly Standard. --Corey Robin, Brooklyn College, SUNY, Newsday, 6/20/2001 The editors, who differ on recount questions, have been careful to balance opinions in their column selections. --Robert Nardini, Library Journal, 9/24/2001 ... makes for entertaining and informative reading to see such contrasts in opinion. --Kenneth R. Mayer, Congress & the Presidency, 10/1/2001 Bush v. Gore [is] a well-edited, balanced work... The book collects the principal decisions and varied and thought-provoking views on the main facets of the battle. --Steven I. Himelstein, Dorsey & Whitney LLP (Law firm), New York Law Journal, 5/4/2001

About the Author

E.J. Dionne Jr. is a senior fellow at the Brookings Institution, cochair of the Pew Forum on Religion and Public Life, and a syndicated columnist for the Washington Post Writers Group. William Kristol is editor and publisher of The Weekly Standard.

More books by this author
Author 'Like for Like' recommendations

Loading other formats...

Book Info

Publication date

1st February 2001


E. J., Jr. Dionne

More books by E. J., Jr. Dionne
Author 'Like for Like'


Brookings Institution


360 pages


Elections & referenda
Constitution: government & the state



It's information about new books so, for a book lover like me, what's not to like!

Joan Hill

If you love reading, then you'll love Lovereading! Full of tips & info for every discerning reader.

Lynne Rapson

Why I love @lovereadinguk? It's in the name - as dedicated lovers of reading, they are perfect matchmakers for helping me find my next read!

Catherine Jenkins

Ever purchased a book, read a few pages & thought I'm not going to enjoy this? Honest book reviews mean you'll never have that problem again

Jill Peters

If you LOVE reading then you will love LOVEREADING! It's a 'novel' idea. Seriously though I could not recommend them enough.

Rebecca Whymark

Lovereading helps me decide what real people read.

Kerry Bridges

It gives a chance to read about new titles, invites comments from all kinds of readers and is run by such a nice bunch of book lovers.

Joy Bosworth

Lovereading is like booking a holiday, you don't know what it will be like and it is a whole new experience.

Sue Burton