book price comparison hold back the stars
Search our site
Are You Sleeping by Kathleen Barber Read the opening extract of the brand new Kathleen Barber book before its publication on 27/12/2017

The American Indian and the Problem of History by Calvin (Rutgers University) Martin

The American Indian and the Problem of History


The American Indian and the Problem of History by Calvin (Rutgers University) Martin

The problem of history for North American Indians is that historical consciousness has traditionally been irrelevent to them, perhaps even dangerous. Time, with its attendant experiences, realities, and knowledge, was not linear, progressive, and novel. Their vision of themselves in relation to the cosmos was very different from the anthropocentric perspective that came to dominate Western thinking. Each of the eighteen authors herein wrestles with the phenomenon that in writing about Indians and whites in concert scholars are perforce trying to mesh two very different structures and systems of reality and knowledge-two fundamentally different cosmologies-which in fact do not really fit together. In essays written especially for this volume, each scholar confronts the problem from his or her distinct experience as historian, anthropologist, professional writer, Native or non-Native American. This in not a book about methodology; it probes far deeper than that. It questions whether formal Western history has the philosophical power and imagination to enable scholars to write about life and world societies who were conceived in history, who did not willingly launch themselves out onto an historical trajectory, and who performed in the Western vision and errand of history only through coercion. Here, then, is a study of the metaphysics of writing Indian-white history.


A lively and positive collection of essays on the nature, process, and interpretation of history in its many forms. It is an enlightening book which cuts to the heart of the matter of history and Indians. -Roy Wortman, Kenyon College Martin's collection provides a bracing antidote to conventional historiography. -Great Plains Quarterly Useful for upper division undergraduates and for scholars wishing to sample the intense historiographical debate within ethnohistory. -The Western Historical Quarterly [An] important book...written for those concerned with writing Native American history, anthropology, and 'ethnohistory,
but it also speaks to the approaches taken by social scientists examining different cultures

....Those actively working in the field of American Indian history and those thinking of entering the field would do well to read this thoughtful and challenging collection. -Wisconsin Magazine of History An excellent analysis of the evolving methodology and metaphysics of the 'New Indian History.'...These through-provoking essays are highly recommended. -Choice The most challenging volume on the historiography of Indian-white relations yet published....[The] volume must have an impact on the conduct of history and the social sciences in their dealings with tribal peoples. The collection is certainly among the best of the recent critiques of the social sciences. -South Dakota History

About the Author

Loading other formats...

Book Info

Publication date

22nd January 1987


Calvin (Rutgers University) Martin

More books by Calvin (Rutgers University) Martin
Author 'Like for Like'


Oxford University Press Inc


256 pages


Ethnic studies
History: theory & methods



Lovereading is a wonderful way to expand my literary horizons, discover inspiring authors & get the chance to read new novels first. #loveit

Zarina de Ruiter

Lovereading is not only an amazing site, but it's one of my very favourites. It's like visiting a fascinating bookstore, but better.

Rebecca Jayne Barrett

With literary excellence, humour and drama, Lovereading's got value and is a real stress-calmer!

Siobhan McDowell

You can trust Lovereading to show unbiased reviews by actual, ordinary readers that help likeminded booklovers choose their next great read.

Linda Hill

Lovereading is an amazing place to be, the website is wonderful and to me if I'm sad I'll go here and it cheers me up!

Sophia Upton

Hooked on books? Give Lovereading a go - for the chance to discover brilliant books, and to see why our members love it so.

Claire Hill

Lovereading is a world of books. It has everything you need from new to old and much loved classic books. It even give you recommendations!

Kate Thurston

I love the honest opinions, recommendations for every genre and every reader, wish lists and Like for Like.

Amrita Dasgupta