Tell us a story

LoveReading is thrilled to announce the launch of The Very Short Story Award 2019! If you think you have a story we'll love, click here to find out more and how to enter:

Find out more

Why Not Me? A Story of Love and Loss

by Barbara Want

Biography / Autobiography

LoveReading View on Why Not Me? A Story of Love and Loss


March 2010 Editor's Choice.


An incredibly moving account of a widow’s grief, this does not make for comfortable reading all of the time but it is a raw and honest account of the various stages that grief takes on and how one woman is coping. Whether you have had a similar experience or not this is a compelling, powerful and emotional read.


Editor's Choice reduced logo


Dear Reader,

Why Not Me? is the deeply effecting memoir of a young mother whose husband died of cancer three years ago, leaving her with twin sons, aged four.   It may seem a strange recommendation for an Editor’s Choice: there is no ‘happy ending’, no easy solution. But the book deserves to be championed  because of  the breath-taking,  even brutal, candour with which the author describes her predicament.  The sheer force of the writing distinguishes this book –  it has a beautiful clear voice, and a remarkable lack of inhibition.

Barbara’s husband Nick, the much-loved presenter of BBC’s World At One, was first diagnosed with a rare cancer in 2003.    Almost overnight Barbara had to adapt to becoming the prime carer of a disabled person, and then a widow and a single mother. 

Whether it’s her account of the initial diagnosis, their  trip to hospital for the amputation, her last minutes with Nick before he died, having to tell the boys that Daddy had gone, she has a cinematographic ability to relay each scene in unforgettable clarity.  Her experience of losing the man she loved so much, of her subsequent breakdown, of attempting to have a relationship with another man - much to some of her friends’ disapproval - are all recounted with intimate precision. 

The title of the book comes from something Nick said to Barbara when he was first diagnosed:

I don’t spend a lot of time thinking, ‘Why me?’  People always say that’s what you must think but I don’t.  If you’re slightly fatalistic about cancer, as I am, then you always think ‘why not me?’ 
  (Audio Diary April 4th 2006)

Barbara’s book will surely give enormous comfort to anyone suffering the loss of a loved one, as well as giving anyone trying to be supportive a greater understanding of what it’s like to be bereaved. 

 I hope you’ll agree that Why Not Me? is an exceptional piece of writing – and an unforgettable memoir.


Lucinda McNeile

Weidenfeld & Nicolson

Why Not Me? A Story of Love and Loss Synopsis

This haunting memoir of grief recounts the death from cancer of Nick Clarke, much-loved BBC radio presenter of 'The World at One' - and the aftermath - from his widow Barbara's point of view.


With painful honesty, Barbara lays open her ambivalent feelings about the illness as it progressed, and her instinctive fear that this would be the end. As he got sicker, her fear grew, until he died an unfeasibly short time after his diagnosis.


Barbara chronicles in unflinching prose her life after his death. A howl of anguish and anger, she describes how many of her friends and colleagues don't call, and don't offer support - how alone she is, and how she struggles to explain the unexplainable to her young twin sons. She has a breakdown, and a short-lived relationship (met with condemnation from some of her friends) but knows the process of dealing with her grief is barely beginning.


A ruthlessly honest dissection of a widow's pain, this book is also a love story - an uncomfortably raw, utterly compelling memoir which ends without resolution; its author still fighting to come to terms with the hand life has dealt her.

If you loved this, you might like these...

Bella Figura
Jo Malone: My Story
The Life and Times of a Very British Man
More Dashing Further Letters of Patrick Leigh Fermor

All versions of this book

ISBN: 9780297851875
Publication date: 11/03/2010
Publisher: Weidenfeld & Nicolson an imprint of Orion Publishing Co
Format: Hardback

Book Information

ISBN: 9780297851875
Publication date: 11th March 2010
Author: Barbara Want
Publisher: Weidenfeld & Nicolson an imprint of Orion Publishing Co
Format: Hardback
Genres: Biography / Autobiography,

About Barbara Want

Barbara Want is a former BBC radio producer. This is her first book.

More About Barbara Want

Share this book